How to Get a Domestic Violence Case Dismissed in California (8 Ways)

How to Get a Domestic Violence Case Dismissed in California (8 Ways)

There are 8 ways to get a domestic violence case dismissed in California: 

  1. Insufficient Evidence
  2. Violation of Rights
  3. Self-Defense or Defense of Others
  4. Victim Recantation
  5. Diversion Programs
  6. Civil Compromise
  7. Pretrial Motions
  8. Prosecutorial Discretion

Whether it’s strained relationships with loved ones or the looming threat of a tarnished reputation, the impact of a domestic abuse allegation can be profound. Having a trusted legal team by your side can mean the difference of winning a case or losing it. Reclaim your reputation and life by contacting Mariya Melkonyan for a confidential consultation today.

Quick Overview: Penalties for Domestic Violence in California

California takes domestic violence very seriously, with significant penalties for those who commit such offenses. Under California Penal Code 273.5, domestic violence is willfully inflicting corporal injury resulting in a traumatic condition upon an intimate partner. Here are the penalties for different levels of domestic violence: 

Misdemeanor Penalties:

  • Up to one year in county jail.
  • Fines up to $6,000.
  • Probation of up to three years.
  • Mandatory completion of a batterer’s intervention program.

Felony Penalties:

  • Imprisonment in state prison for up to four years.
  • Additional penalties if the defendant has prior convictions or aggravated circumstances are present.
  • Other penalties:
  • Issuance of a protective or restraining order prohibiting contact with the victim.
  • Payment for the victim’s medical expenses, counseling, or other losses incurred due to the offense.
  • Conviction may result in loss of firearm ownership rights under federal and state law.
  • Child abuse charges if DV happens in front of children.

Can You Get Domestic Violence Charges Dropped in California?

Domestic violence charges can be dropped in California under certain circumstances. Here are some reasons why:

  • Defendants may be eligible for pre-trial diversion programs, leading to dismissal upon completion.
  • In misdemeanor cases, charges may be dropped if the victim and defendant reach a civil compromise.
  • Charges may be dropped if there is insufficient evidence to support prosecution.
  • Defense attorneys can file legal motions to dismiss charges if procedural errors or rights violations occur.
  • Effective defense strategies or negotiated plea deals may lead to dropped charges or reduced penalties. Reach out to Melkonyan Law Firm’s services for expert assistance in defense against domestic violence charges.

Who Has the Authority to Drop Domestic Violence Charges in California?

In California, the decision to drop domestic violence charges typically rests with the prosecuting attorney, who represents the state in criminal proceedings. However, there are other ways how to get a domestic violence case dismissed in California:

  • The victim can influence prosecutors by refusing to cooperate or testify, potentially leading to dropped charges.
  • The judge can dismiss charges if insufficient evidence or legal issues warrant dismissal.
  • The defense attorney can negotiate with the prosecutor for dismissal or reduction of charges through plea bargaining or legal motions → that’s why it’s so important to get proper legal representation.

How to Get a Domestic Violence Case Dismissed in California (8 Ways)

Facing a domestic violence case in California can be overwhelming, but understanding the avenues available for dismissal can provide some clarity and hope. If you’re wondering, “Can you get domestic violence charges dropped,” here are 8 effective strategies to try out:

  1. Encourage victim refusal to cooperate: Sometimes, if the victim refuses to cooperate or testify, prosecutors might drop the charges.
  2. Seek competent legal representation: Get a good lawyer who knows how to handle domestic violence cases. They can talk to the prosecutors and convince them to drop the charges if the evidence is weak or the victim changes their story.
  3. Explore pre-trial diversion programs: Look into pre-trial diversion programs. If you qualify and complete one, it might lead to the case being dismissed.
  4. Pursue civil compromise: If it’s a misdemeanor, you might be able to work things out with the victim. If they agree, the charges could get dropped.
  5. Challenge evidence sufficiency: Your lawyer can challenge whether the evidence is good enough to hold up in court. If it’s not, the case might get thrown out.
  6. Employ effective defense strategies: Your lawyer can use smart legal moves to defend you. Find out more about these defense strategies here.
  7. Negotiate plea deals: Sometimes, you can make a deal with the prosecutors. If you agree to certain terms, you might get the charges dropped or reduced.
  8. File legal motions: If there were mistakes or violations of your rights during the legal process, your lawyer can file motions to dismiss the charges.

For expert guidance and support in navigating your domestic violence case and implementing these strategies, consider contacting Melkonyan Law Firm. Our experienced team provides expert legal help and will fight for the best outcome for your case.

6 Factors Affecting Whether Your DV Case Gets Dismissed

Various factors influence whether a domestic violence case in California gets dismissed. Understanding these factors is crucial for individuals facing such allegations, as well as their legal representation.

1. Insufficient Evidence

Insufficient evidence may lead to the dismissal of domestic violence (DV) cases. Prosecutors assess evidence to determine if it meets the threshold for prosecution since it must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. 

Without sufficient evidence, the case may not proceed to trial or may be dismissed during pre-trial hearings. Defense attorneys can challenge evidence’s sufficiency through legal motions, seeking dismissal. Learn more about how a domestic violence attorney can help here.

2. Inconsistent Statements

Inconsistent statements by the accuser can raise doubts about their credibility. Defense attorneys may highlight inconsistencies to challenge the accuser’s reliability, weakening the prosecution’s case during trial. If inconsistencies significantly undermine the case’s integrity, the prosecution may opt to dismiss the charges.

3. Self-Defense Claim

If the defendant can establish self-defense, it may lead to dismissal or acquittal. Evidence supporting self-defense, like injuries on the defendant or a history of violence by the victim, can strengthen the case. Prosecutors assess the validity of self-defense claims before deciding whether to proceed with charges.

4. Accidental Injury

If the alleged domestic violence incident resulted from an accident, it may lead to dismissal. Evidence supporting the accidental nature of the injury, such as eyewitness testimony or forensic evidence, is crucial. Prosecutors consider whether the injury was truly accidental or if there’s evidence of intentional harm before making charging decisions.

5. No Visible Injuries

A lack of visible injuries can challenge the prosecution’s case, especially if the alleged victim claims violence — this may bring the victim’s credibility into question. Prosecutors assess the overall evidence, including testimony and medical reports, to determine the case’s strength. 

If the lack of visible injuries significantly weakens the case or raises doubts about the alleged violence, they may dismiss the charges. In these cases, you may be charged with domestic battery instead. Learn more about domestic battery here.

6. No Independent Witnesses

A lack of independent witnesses makes it harder to corroborate the alleged victim’s version of events, casting doubt on the credibility of the alleged victim’s testimony. The prosecution’s case may lack sufficient evidence to proceed, potentially leading to dismissal.

What Happens When a Domestic Violence Case Is Dismissed in California?

When a domestic violence case is dismissed in California, several important outcomes follow:

1. Formal closure by the court: The court formally closes the domestic violence case, signaling the end of legal proceedings against the accused.

2. Absence of conviction: The accused is not convicted of domestic violence and is freed from legal consequences such as fines, probation, or incarceration.

3. Record clearance or sealing: Depending on state laws and procedures, the arrest record associated with the dismissed case may be eligible for clearance or sealing. This can help mitigate the impact of the arrest on the individual’s future opportunities and reputation. Learn more about California SB 731.

4. Civil remedies: Following dismissal, the accused may pursue civil remedies, like seeking damages for wrongful arrest or defamation. This compensates for any harm or injustice resulting from the arrest and allegations.

Alternative Solutions if Dismissal Is Not Feasible or Advisable

When dismissal is not feasible or advisable, your domestic attorney will pursue other strategies to get the best outcome for your case, including:

  • Negotiate with prosecutors for reduced charges or penalties in exchange for a guilty plea.
  • Get you the option to participate in Deferred Entry of Judgement (DEJ) programs where charges are deferred pending completion of counseling or rehabilitation.
  • Get you the option to enroll in diversion programs focusing on anger management or substance abuse treatment to address underlying issues.
  • Accept probation with conditions such as counseling, community service, or stay-away orders.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

This section provides concise answers to common questions about domestic violence cases.

How long do most domestic violence cases last?

The duration of domestic violence cases varies widely based on factors like case complexity, court backlog, and legal procedures. Pre-trial motions, negotiations, and discovery processes also contribute to case duration. Many cases resolve within several months to a year, but some complex cases may take longer.

How long does the District Attorney (DA) have to file charges in California?

In California, the statute of limitations for most felony offenses, including domestic violence, is generally three years. For misdemeanor offenses, including some domestic violence cases, the statute of limitations is typically one year. Certain circumstances, such as DNA evidence or crimes against minors, may extend or eliminate the statute of limitations.

How to drop domestic violence charges against someone?

Start by consulting with an attorney to understand the legal implications and ensure your rights are protected. The attorney will file a motion with the court to dismiss the charges on your behalf and provide legal representation and guidance throughout the process. You may need to sign documents, such as a non-prosecution affidavit expressing their desire to drop charges. Ensure you communicate openly with your attorney and follow their legal advice. If the judge approves the dismissal, the charges will be dropped, and the case will be closed.

Protect Your Rights: Secure Expert Legal Help for Domestic Violence Charges

Domestic violence charges are complex and can lead to serious penalties, including fines, probation, incarceration, and long-term consequences such as damage to reputation and loss of certain rights. Considering the gravity of these outcomes, it’s crucial to have the help of a knowledgeable attorney as soon as possible. An expert can navigate the complexities of the legal system and build a strong defense strategy for your case, increasing the chance of a successful outcome. 

Don’t delay securing the assistance you need to protect your rights and future. With 13 years of experience as a former Deputy District Attorney, Attorney Maryia Melkonyan will use her expertise in domestic battery cases to fight for you and ensure no stone is left unturned.  Schedule your free, no-obligation case review today.

Frequently Asked Questions

During your free initial consultation, your attorney will discuss the facts of your case, getting a clear overview of your situation. Your attorney will then explain the process, letting you know what will be expected of you and the support and services they will offer.

Your attorney will then guide you on how to proceed and begin collecting potential witness details to support your case and evidence for preservation, proper representation, and preparation. Finally, we will explain our fees, take you through our retainer form, and answer any queries you have.

To give Mariya a clear view of your case, you must provide them with as many details and as much evidence about your case as possible. This may include documentation, videos, audio files, witness names, time logs on any information related to the case for review. The more details and evidence you can provide, the better case your attorney can build right from the start.

Some clients are concerned about revealing too much to a lawyer in an initial consultation, but your meetings with an attorney are confidential and protected by client/attorney privilege.

After your initial consultation, we’ll be able to determine a retainer fee and discuss payment options. In most cases, the retainer feee payments are divided into two parts; the first is typically payable upfront.

There are various options for paying your retainer fee, including cash, check, or card.

There is no one-size-fits-all cost for an attorney to defend your criminal case. The fee depends on the charges against you and the details of your specific case. As a rule, open misdemeanor cases tend to be charged at a lower fee than open felony cases. Post-conviction legal services, such as expungement of criminal records, are usually even less expensive.

The final fee depends on the complexity of your case. During your consultation, the attorney will discuss the fees with you. The more details you can give about your case, the more accurate expectations your attorney can set. Contact Mariya today for a no-obligation case review.

Book A Free Consultation

Fill out the form below to request a call back and a free initial consultation.

    Book A Free Consultation

    Fill out the form below to request a call back and a free initial consultation.

      Recent Blogs

      Frequently Asked Questions

      During your free initial consultation, your attorney will discuss the facts of your case, getting a clear overview of your situation. Your attorney will then explain the process, letting you know what will be expected of you and the support and services they will offer.

      Your attorney will then guide you on how to proceed and begin collecting potential witness details to support your case and evidence for preservation, proper representation, and preparation. Finally, we will explain our fees, take you through our retainer form, and answer any queries you have.

      To give Mariya a clear view of your case, you must provide them with as many details and as much evidence about your case as possible. This may include documentation, videos, audio files, witness names, time logs on any information related to the case for review. The more details and evidence you can provide, the better case your attorney can build right from the start.

      Some clients are concerned about revealing too much to a lawyer in an initial consultation, but your meetings with an attorney are confidential and protected by client/attorney privilege.

      After your initial consultation, we’ll be able to determine a retainer fee and discuss payment options. In most cases, the retainer feee payments are divided into two parts; the first is typically payable upfront.

      There are various options for paying your retainer fee, including cash, check, or card.

      There is no one-size-fits-all cost for an attorney to defend your criminal case. The fee depends on the charges against you and the details of your specific case. As a rule, open misdemeanor cases tend to be charged at a lower fee than open felony cases. Post-conviction legal services, such as expungement of criminal records, are usually even less expensive.

      The final fee depends on the complexity of your case. During your consultation, the attorney will discuss the fees with you. The more details you can give about your case, the more accurate expectations your attorney can set. Contact Mariya today for a no-obligation case review.